2002 (January to June)
–Detective Comics #654-656
Early January. The General, a teenage delinquent in the vein of Anarky, begins assembling Gotham’s gangs into a giant anti-Batman army. The army eventually strikes, but it’s not enough to overcome the weary, but stalwart Batman. Bane observes the Dark Knight from afar, studying his every move and tactic.
–REFERENCE: In Batman: Shadow of the Bat #19-20 and Batman: Shadow of the Bat #34. Batman deals with mafiosos in the Buto Family, led by their patriarch Joey Buto.
–FLASHBACK: From the B&W second feature to Batman: Gotham Knights #47. Batman protects Commissioner Gordon and Sarah Essen Gordon when Riddler invades their home.
–Robin III #1
In Robin III Tim is portrayed as a freshman in high school and depicted as being around 14-years-old. However, due to retcons, he should actually only be in junior high and only 11-years-old. Batman and Robin take down a White Power gang known as the White Wolves. Across town Huntress spies on top mobster Tony Bressi (who we haven’t seen since Year Seven)! Later, Tim attends the birthday party of his friend Sebastian Ives in Litte Odessa, Gotham’s Russian neighborhood. He overhears some of Bressi’s thugs roughing-up a local shopkeeper and helps him out. Tim meets the shopkeeper’s daughter Ariana Dzerchenko, whom he will begin dating in a year or so. After that, Tim meets with his wheelchair-bound dad, who has finally returned home from the hospital. With dad home, Tim will have to start doing a lot of sneaking around to attend to his vigilante duties as Robin from now on. When Bressi’s men go after the Dzerchenkos again, Robin is on hand and winds up facing off head-to-head with the returning KGBeast! NOTE: The rest of Robin III (Robin III #2-6) happens right after Robin III #1 ends. These issues are very important continuity-wise, but I’ve left them off the timeline simply because Batman is not in them.
FUNERAL FOR A FRIEND
———————–Justice League America #70
———————–Superman: The Man of Steel #20
———————–Superman Vol. 2 #76
———————–Superman: The Man of Steel #21
It’s taken a while to organize Superman’s public funeral ceremony. Literally all the superheroes attend the service. Batman, along with hundreds of thousands, mourn Superman’s passing. Bill and Hillary Clinton attend as well, but the correct president at the time, due to retcons, should either be George W or some generic fictional prez. Issue #21 is the seventh part of Superman’s funeral. Jeez, no one else could have ever warranted multiple issues for funeral coverage, let alone seven of ’em.
March. In issue #489 Killer Croc says he last fought Batman six months ago in August. Six months ago should correctly be late September. Moving onto a synopsis. Snow falls over Gotham. Bruce takes sedatives as prescribed by Shondra. While he is out-of-action, Killer Croc goes on a rampage. Robin dresses Jean-Paul up as Batman (some foreshadowing huh?) and they go to confront Croc. But before they have a chance to do anything, Bane is already there and he absolutely destroys Croc, snapping his arm like a twig. NOTE: All the heroes around this time (including Robin and Jean-Paul) sport black Superman arm bands in honor of the fallen Man of Steel. Pretty cool. In issue #490 Bane injects the Riddler with Venom (!) and the pumped-up Nigma goes berserk. Once Bruce realizes Venom is involved, he solemnly recalls the dark time he spent getting to know the drug far too well (see the Bat Year Three for details). This mention is notable because it was the first time in the Modern Age that any LOTDK stories were specifically canonically referenced by an author!
–Black Condor #12
Batman teams-up with Black Condor in the final issue of this series.
–Showcase ’93 #6
Robin takes down gangster Ramon Bracuda on a solo mission, but Bracuda goes free due to circumstantial evidence. Robin then uses himself as bait to entrap Bracuda and send him to prison for good. Batman secretly watches Robin from afar and proudly approves of his methods.
–Detective Comics #657-658
Batman, Robin, and Azrael prevent Cypher from using his hypnotism to command Lucius Fox to commit suicide.
–Batman/Judge Dredd: Vendetta in Gotham
Judge Dredd (from an alternate post-apocalyptic Earth in the twenty-second century) returns to Earth-0 to pick a fight with Batman. After battling for nearly forty-five minutes straight, Dredd reveals that Batman was set to die earlier in the night from an explosion involving the Ventriloquist—citing a Gotham newspaper from the next day. Dredd was merely keeping Batman occupied to save his life. Realizing that children are in danger, Batman takes-off to the Ventriloquist’s location, where the mad villain (with Scarface) is attempting to blow up a stage-play of Goldilocks and the Three Bears being performed for a senator’s family and a bunch of kids. Dredd follows and helps Batman not only bring down the Ventriloquist, but save everyone’s lives too. Before departing, Dredd reveals that he only saved Batman’s life because a telepath on his Earth predicted that Batman will help save Mega-City One from a dire threat one day in the future.
–Batman: The Last Angel
Catwoman dons a new tiger-striped costume (which only lasts for this story) and attempts to steal an ancient Mayan bat mask from the museum. Batman is able to stop her, but once he touches the artifact, he becomes possessed by an evil Mayan god. Luckily, Catwoman is able to stop Batman before he can do anything terrible. The secret reveal and one-shot return villain in this story? Rupert Thorne! Catwoman directly references the events of Detective Comics #469-476 (Bat Year Nine) where Thorne had ascended to the top of the mob food-chain in Gotham only to be institutionalized after being terrorized by the supposed “ghost” of Hugo Strange. With Catwoman’s assistance, Thorne is now rehabilitated and wilier than ever. However, Batman is able to take him down and make Thorne’s return short and sweet.
–Batman versus Predator II: Bloodmatch #1-4
Late March. This tale supposedly occurs the summer following Batman versus Predator #1-3. However, the whole Bane saga gets in the way of that logic. Therefore, we must ignore the specific summer setting. It’s late March. Onto the synopsis. Batman stalks drug pusher Johnny Panetti—representing the mobster Manny Terraro—to the waterfront where he surveils a dockside drug deal between Panetti and some Columbian thugs. When Panetti double-crosses the thugs and shoots them dead, Batman swoops down to kick ass, receiving some unwelcome assistance from Huntress. Panetti tells Batman that Terraro has put a high-paying underworld hit out on him. As Batman patrols, a returning Predator alien, having returned to Earth to hunt Batman, attacks Commissioner Gordon at Police HQ, stealing the Batsignal in the process. The Predator then knocks-out Huntress and decapitates some of Terraro’s men. In the forest outside of Gotham, the Predator calls Batman by shining the Batsignal into the air. Batman fights a losing battle against the Predator in the woods, getting tied up and hung upside down. Huntress arrives again and saves Batman. A stuttering Terraro-hired hitman, in an attempt to kill Batman, blows up the Batmobile, which actually allows the heroes to escape. The Predator kills the hitman. Back in Gotham, Huntress gives Batman a list of assassins on his tail. Batman trains with Alfred in the Batcave while Huntress makes herself bait to lure the other hitmen away from the Caped Crusader. After building a signal scrambler (designed to eliminate the Predator’s ability to turn invisible) and meeting briefly with Huntress, Batman returns home to test the scrambler on Alfred’s TV. We learn that Alfred has a cozy home theater living room setup in the Batcave, which he uses to record and watch daytime soaps! Batman and Huntress then both converge on Terraro’s penthouse where they fight a Hong Kong assassin and the Predator, who instantly kills Terraro. While Huntress defeats the assassin, Batman chases away the Predator. Meanwhile, two more Predators, sent from their home world to kill the Predator that stalks Batman (who has apparently gone rogue, striking at Batman without permission), engage with their target. However, the rogue Predator kills one of them. Batman meets the other Predator briefly before returning home. After dispatching of another hitman, Batman meets Commissioner Gordon’s new personal staffer Lieutenant Frank Stocker, two “Men in Black” CIA agents that have information about the Predators, and a pipe-smoking Commissioner Gordon. (The pipe is odd since, at this juncture, Gordon would have quit smoking. Could this be a non-nicotine puff puff? Either that or it is a continuity error.) The group lights up a brand new Batsignal as a lure for the rogue Predator, but both Predators show up. The CIA agents shoot at the wrong Predator and get their heads chopped off for their mistake. The rogue Predator kidnaps Lieutenant Stocker, forcing Batman and Huntress to follow back into the woods. They wind up aboard the rogue Predator’s spaceship, which rockets over Gotham. Batman and Huntress are knocked-out, but Lieutenant Stocker sacrifices his own life to kill the rogue Predator. Batman and Huntress plunge into the bay below just in time to witness the good Predator sacrifice his own life by crashing his spaceship into the rogue Predator’s spaceship (not knowing he had already been killed). Batman tells Huntress to piss off. Commissioner Gordon lights up the Batsignal to alert Batman to a new murder spree by an escaped Joker. It’s back to business as usual just like that. We can presume that Batman brings Joker to justice and returns him to Arkham (where we next will see the villain).
–FLASHBACK: From Batman and Superman: World’s Finest #9, Part 1. Late March. In Metropolis, Batman meets the substitute Supermen—Superboy (Kon-El, who later takes the name “Conner Kent”), Steel (John Henry Irons), Cyborg Superman (Hank Henshaw), and The Eradicator. The Dark Knight helps the Substitute Superman defeat another group of fake villainous Superman, including crook Lonnie Riven. As soon as he returns to Gotham, Bane will unleash hell on Batman and all of Gotham.
———————–Detective Comics #659
———————–Detective Comics #660
———————–Detective Comics #661
Bane destroys Arkham unleashing every insane criminal Batman has ever apprehended. Bruce, Tim, and Jean-Paul (and Alfred, Ace, Harold, and Huntress) have their work cut out for them. The good guys recapture Mad Hatter, Mr. Zsasz, Amygdala, Cornelius Stirk, the Cavalier, and Poison Ivy. Bane kills Film Freak. Robin gets caught in the middle of a brutal Bane vs Killer Croc rematch. Elsewhere, an alien menace has reared its ugly head, which leads us to a slight interlude known as “Bloodlines.”
———————–Batman: Shadow of the Bat Annual #1
Xenomorph-like shape-shifting aliens (known as Bloodlines Parasites) are feeding off human spinal fluid. Once fed upon, the human fodder dies, except for a select few who gain metahuman powers instead. Don’t ask me how or why. It’s stupid. It’s “Bloodlines.” In SotB Annual #1 Batman teams-up with the returning Pagan and the debuting Joe Public.
———————–Detective Comics #662
———————–Detective Comics #663
———————–Detective Comics #664
———————–Showcase ’93 #7-8 (“2 FACE”)
———————–Detective Comics #665
———————–Batman: Shadow of the Bat #16-18 (“GOD OF FEAR”)
Mid April. Batman and Robin recapture Firefly and the Riddler. Batman rescues Mayor Krol from the Scarecrow and the Joker. The Dark Knight also apprehends Two-Face after he holds a twisted “trial” against the Caped Crusader. And last but not least, Batman defeats Bane’s three tough henchmen, Bird, Trogg, and Zombie. After all of this insanity Bruce returns to Wayne Manor in a weakened, fragile state only to discover a beaten Alfred and Bane awaiting him. Bane has known Batman’s true identity for some time now. Bruce is barely able to contend with the powerful behemoth and is tossed around the Batcave like a rag-doll. In one of the most iconic Batman splash pages of all time Bane raises Bruce above his head and literally breaks him in half. Bruce’s back is broken. Bane then hauls Bruce’s limp body downtown and hurls him off of a two-story building in front of countless onlookers. Bane now owns Gotham, but this is just the beginning. (This scene is also shown via flashback from DC Universe Legacies #7). With Bruce out-of-commission Jean-Paul Valley dons the cape and cowl and officially becomes the new Batman. However, Jean-Paul is merciless due to his programming by “The System.” In his first night out, he nearly kills a petty thug with a sledgehammer before Robin stops him. Right away, Tim can tell the new Batman will be more trouble than Bruce bargained for. Jean-Paul eventually tells Robin to stay out of his way, creating a serious rift between the duo. Despite his insane rage and lack of finesse, Jean-Paul is able to recapture the Scarecrow and Anarky by himself. Meanwhile, Bruce begins his recovery and begins a romantic relationship with Dr. Shondra Kinsolving, but before it can fully develop, Jack Drake and Shondra are kidnapped and taken out of the country.
———————–Batman Annual #17
Batman (Jean-Paul) teams-up with the debuting Ballistic against the alien parasites who just won’t go away.
–NOTE: In Justice League Task Force #1. The UN sanctions a new splinter version of the Justice League known as the Justice League Task Force which is led by Martian Manhunter and has a rotating roster of members. Nightwing is a founding member, but quits after only one mission.
———————–Catwoman Vol. 2 #2
———————–Justice League Task Force #4
In Catwoman Vol. 2 #2 Selina Kyle’s apartment explodes nearly killing her. She soon learns that her case is related to the kidnapping case involving Jack Drake and Shondra Kinsolving. In issue #499 a wheelchair-bound Bruce, Alfred, and a stowaway Selina go on a globe-trotting search for the kidnapped Mr. Drake and Shondra. Bruce and Alfred make cameos in Justice League Task Force #4 where they ask Martian Manhunter for help from the JLTF. Meanwhile back in Gotham, Jean-Paul prepares for the inevitable confrontation with Bane by designing new high-tech Bat-gloves complete with razor sharp claws.
———————–Robin Annual #2
———————–Detective Comics Annual #6
Robin teams-up with the debuting Razorsharp and The Psyba-Rats against the alien parasites. Jean-Paul field tests his new high-tech Bat-gloves as he teams-up with the debuting Geist against those dastardly extraterrestrials. NOTE: Jean-Paul says he became Azrael a year ago. Not true, more like months ago.
———————–Detective Comics #666
Great two issues to wrap-up “Knightfall.” Batman has been increasingly violent recently and Commissioner Gordon can’t understand what has happened to his Dark Knight. Jean-Paul finally takes on Bane and it’s a pretty even match, but Bane beats him. (This battle is also shown through flashback from DC Universe Legacies #7.) Disgruntled, Jean-Paul does something never before done in the history of Batman; he creates a whole new Bat-suit, which is sleek, heavily armored, loaded to the teeth with weaponry, and looks much like his technophilic Azrael costume. Some will always say that “Az-Bats” is complete and utter blasphemy, but I always loved it. I mean, this isn’t Bruce. This is the borderline psychotic Jean-Paul. Jean-Paul would do something like this. At the end of issue #500, which has an amazing gate-fold cover, the new-and-improved Batman is able to do what Bruce wasn’t able to—he beats the shit out of Bane. “Az-Bats” is here to stay. (Bane’s defeat is also depicted in added detail through flashback from DC Universe Legacies #7). After Bane’s thrashing, Robin takes his torn luchador mask, which is repaired—likely by Alfred—and later put on display in the Batcave trophy area (as referenced in Batman Versus Predator III: Blood Ties #3).
–Showcase ’93 #10
Az-Bats travels to Colorado and assists the Huntress in capturing some criminals who have fled there from Gotham.
–FLASHBACK: From Primal Force #7. Az-Bats viciously (and unnecessarily) assaults some car-jackers.
–Batman: Turning Points #4
Gordon is becoming distraught about the new Batman. He even visits Blackgate, where Bane assures him that there is a new person under the mask and cowl. Dejected over the fact that he doesn’t have definitive answers, and feeling betrayed by the Bat-Family, Gordon trudges on. This is also the first chronological debut of the brash, Rambo-esque GCPD officer Billy Petit, who will be an important player during the events of “No Man’s Land” later on.
–NOTE: In “Reign of the Supermen!” aka “The Return of Superman” arc. Superman, about five-and-a-half months after his death, is resurrected after his corpse is put into an ancient Kryptonian regeneration matrix device. With Hal Jordan, Superman is able to defeat Mongul and Cyborg Superman, but not before the complete destruction of Coast City results in the deaths of over a hundred-thousand people. Coast City is the West Coast equivalent of Metropolis, so this is a pretty big deal.
The world celebrates the return of Superman, while at the same time plans a memorial service in tribute to the tragedy that has befallen Coast City. Superman meets the new Batman and invites him to the Coast City memorial service with the rest of the superheroes. Jean-Paul, in a real dick-move, refuses to attend.
–FLASHBACK: From Batman & Superman: World’s Finest #9, Part 2. Az-Bats meets with Superman for the second time. They team-up to stop a murderous vigilante from executing mob boss Donnie Riven (twin brother of Metropolis crook Lonnie Riven).
KNIGHTQUEST: THE CRUSADE Part One
———————–Batman: Shadow of the Bat #19-20 (“TALLY MAN”)
“Knightquest” begins now and is split into two parts: “The Crusade” chronicles Jean-Paul’s adventures as the new Batman, while “The Search” chronicles the globetrotting adventures of Bruce and Alfred. Jean-Paul struggles to control and understand “The System” programming which rages inside his mind and body. He begins hallucinating visions of a ghostly St. Dumas. The Tally Man makes his debut, hired by the Buto Family to kill Batman. But the Butos don’t know there is a new Batman in town. The Tally Man and Az-Bats go to war. Eventually, the Tally Man is nearly mauled to death by the out-of-control Az-Bats.
———————–Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight Annual #3
“Bloodlines” finally ends (thankfully). Batman (Jean-Paul) deals with the debuting Cardinal Sin and Samaritan, who both gain powers and lose powers in their one-shot issue. The two issues of Bloodbath detail the final attack against the alien parasites, who naturally amalgamate into a single gargantuan mega-monster. Superman leads all of the superheroes into battle, including Nightwing, Robin, and a very anti-social Jean-Paul.
KNIGHTQUEST: THE SEARCH Part One
———————–Justice League Task Force #5-6
———————–Batman: Shadow of the Bat #21-23 (“BRUCE WAYNE”)
Bruce and Alfred land in Santa Prisca and part ways with Selina. Bruce’s JLTF team (consisting of Bronze Tiger, Gypsy, and Green Arrow) storms a compound where Jack and Shondra are being held, but the bad guys are able to escape with their hostages and the chase continues. We also learn that Shondra’s step-brother Benedict Asp is the man responsible for the kidnappings. Bruce (in disguise as British Lord Hemmingford Grey) and Alfred track Asp to London where they hire a local vigilante known as The Hood to aid them in their investigation. Shockingly, Bruce discovers that Shondra was kidnapped because she is a metahuman telekinetic with the power to heal others with her touch. The power-hungry Asp is only able to use his own deadly metahuman psychic powers when he’s in close proximity to his adopted sister. A disguised, cane-hobbling Bruce teams-up with the Hood and together they are able to rescue Jack Drake, but not before Asp escapes with Shondra yet again.
KNIGHTQUEST: THE CRUSADE Part Two
———————–Detective Comics #667-668
———————–Robin Vol. 2 #1-5
———————–Detective Comics #669
———————–Catwoman Vol. 2 #5
———————–Detective Comics #670-673
Summer. At this point in Gotham, it has begun to snow and is supposedly near Christmastime. However, due to retcons, it should correctly be summertime. An excited Robin gets his driver’s license early (ridiculously at age 12) due to his father’s handicap. The Boy Wonder goes to retrieve his car from the Batcave only to learn that Jean-Paul has sealed off his secret entrance. Harold and Ace have left as well. When Jean-Paul catches Robin in the cave, he snaps and attacks him. Robin barely escapes, and this incident pretty much severs the working relationship between the duo. (Although Robin does sneak back into the cave once again to try and reason with Jean-Paul). Batman then obliterates The Trigger Twins, Mekros, and Mr. Freeze. Also, Renee Montoya is promoted to detective. Detective Comics #671-673 contains a great story-arc where the new Batman meets the Joker for the first time! The Joker is filming “The Death of Batman,” complete with a kidnapped film crew, Hollywood producer, and even Siskel and Ebert! There’s a great scene where Siskel and Ebert review Batman’s new costume (Siskel hates it, Ebert loves it), but when they offer critique about the Joker’s film, they each get a bullet in return. Director Joseph Kerr eventually lures Jean-Paul onto the set, but soon dejectedly realizes that Batman is a different person! Batman promptly beats the tar out of Joker, but the Joker escapes custody.
–Chain Gang War #5-6
The homicidal vigilante group known as The Chain Gang is running amok. Jean-Paul engages with them and also meets Deathstroke the Terminator.
KNIGHTQUEST: THE SEARCH Part Two
———————–Catwoman Vol. 2 #6
Catwoman’s investigation into who bombed her apartment leads her back to Gotham where she attempts to steal a deadly neuro-toxin from a warehouse owned by an animal testing lab.
KNIGHTQUEST: THE CRUSADE Part Three
———————–Catwoman Vol. 2 #7
———————–Batman: Shadow of the Bat #24-25
———————–Showcase ’94 #5
———————–Robin Vol. 2 #6
———————–Showcase ’94 #6
———————–Batman: Shadow of the Bat #26-27
———————–Showcase ’94 #7
Batman (Jean-Paul) meets Catwoman for the first time! While she is stealing the aforementioned neuro-toxin (from Catwoman Vol. 2 #6), Batman shows up to stop her. This is a truly great interaction, not because of their epic battle, but because Catwoman knows right away that it isn’t Bruce under the mask. (No sexual chemistry!) Any references to the 1994 World Trade Center bombing are obviously topical. Due to retcons, this story takes place after 9/11, so we can easily replace the 1994 attack with the 2001 attack for the purposes of this tale. Az-Bats then breaks-up a baby smuggling ring. After that he teams-up with Joe Public and they trample the returning Corrosive Man. Next up Jean-Paul gets involved in a mob war featuring cameos by the Huntress, Robin, and the villain known as DeathAngel. Jean-Paul’s war on crime continues as he saves a busload of kids from Abattoir. Abattoir then kidnaps the newborn child of Lady Clay and Preston Payne, Cassius Clay aka Clayface V! Holding the baby hostage, Abattoir blackmails the Clayface parents to attack Batman. Batman easily puts them behind bars and the Clay Baby goes into government custody i.e. a government testing lab. The slippery Abattoir escapes yet again, kidnaps his cousin, and begins slowly torturing him in an abandoned warehouse. Next, the Penguin also meets Batman and realizes there is a new person under the mask! NOTE: Following this case, Lady Clay is sent to a permanent holding cell at STAR Labs.
- COLLIN COLSHER: Welcome to Bat Year Fourteen. “Knightfall” and Zero Hour are the big things that happen this year. Bruce turns 39 in February. Jean-Paul Valley will don the mantle of Batman for approximately four-and-a-half months. As you can see, we have a ton of compression going on here. These stories run the duration of one storyline year (2002), but actually are made up of tales published from April 1993 through December 1995. Wow. This first part of Bat Year Fourteen spans six months.↩
- COLLIN COLSHER: Batman: The Last Angel also serves as the final tale ever written about the defunct Earth-B, which was destroyed during the original Crisis on Infinite Earths. However, it works just as easily on the Modern Age timeline right here and now, hence its placement.↩
- COLLIN COLSHER: See the footnote attached to Batman versus Predator #1-3 in Year Thirteen Part 2 for details on why the Batman versus Predator series should be canon—and then decide for yourself if it truly belongs! Also, don’t forget that the Predators seen in the DCU are wholly separate from the Predators seen in other Dark Horse media or in movies. These are alternate versions that have a unique history within the DCU.↩
- ANTONIO: The only Predator crossover that gives me “feelings of non-canonicity” is B vs P II, for several reasons. The bogus summertime setting and Gordon’s anachronistic pipe smoking are both obvious problems, but the biggest problem is that it seems to have to occur right before “Knightfall.” This feels like a little bit of a reach because around this time Bruce is supposed to be very tired due to his extra overwork—and he doesn’t look exhausted at all in B vs P II. Food for thought.↩
- COLLIN COLSHER: Catwoman Vol. 2 begins during “Knightfall.” It is not to be confused with the first volume of Catwoman, which is the “Year One Era” Catwoman miniseries. Other chronologies on the web sometimes list the first Catwoman series as an unofficial “non-volume” and list Volume 2 as “Volume 1” instead. I, however, find that very confusing and therefore, do not do that.↩
- LANE MCD: I’ve noticed a continuity problem in Batman #499. Bruce and Alfred are boarding a plane for South America to search for information on Bane. Selina Kyle tries to make her way on to the plane. The dialogue between Alfred, Bruce and Selina makes it sound like Alfred has no idea who Selina is and Bruce has only met her once. For example, Alfred says, “Good lord, who are you and how did you get—” and Selina cuts him off with, “My name is Selina Kyle, Mr. Wayne—we met at a charity function and I desperately need to reach Santa Prisca.” This is contained in Year 14 and, granted, there are only a dozen or so stories between Year 1 and 14 (Long Halloween included) that show they have some sort of romance thing in-costume, but even out-of-costume they surely would have had a relationship prior to this.
COLLIN COLSHER: This is indeed an error. But originally, it wasn’t. Let me explain. When Batman #499 originally came out in 1993, Bruce and Selina really had only interacted (out-of-costume) one or two times prior to this and definitely not romantically. When The Long Halloween was published in 1996, it retconned this so that Bruce and Selina did have an intimate relationship outside of their Batman/Catwoman relationship. Thus, even after a lengthy period of non-communication—like ten years from The Long Halloween—Selina would not have responded as she does in Batman #499. We have to ignore that dialogue.↩
- ODI: In KNIGHTQUEST: THE CRUSADE Part Three, Showcase ’94 #5 ends in Robin Vol. 2 #6. There is a panel of both Showcase and Robin Vol. 2 #6 also shown in Batman #507.↩